Cold sandwiches

Our menu

Sandwiches built the way you want them. Fresh breads, meats cut in front of you, then cheese, veggies, and dressing from the lists below.

Sizes run 12", 8", 6", and 4". Prices are listed on each section.

Jay's Original Hoagie sandwich
Hero Hoagies from Jay's Original Hoagies

Hero Hoagies

$14 12" · $11 8" · $8 6" · $6 4"

Italian Special

Ham, Genoa Salami, Capicola

Flying Pig

Turkey, Ham

Michelle

Ham, Cheese

Aiden

Turkey, Cheese

Alan

Turkey, Salami

The Matt

Salami, Cheese

Nana's

Chicken Salad

Steve

Tuna Salad

Cheese Lover

No Meat

Superhero Hoagies from Jay's Original Hoagies

Superhero Hoagies

$15 12" · $12 8" · $9 6" · $7 4"

Monster

Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef

The Dr. Clyde

Turkey, Roast Beef

Jay's Fav!

Roast Beef, Cheese

Alternatives

Da Nicky (Veggie)

$11 12" · $8 8" · $6 6" · $4 4"

Salad

No bread · $7.50 ($2 no meat)

Extra Meat

12" $4 · 6" $2

Meal Deal

Drink + Chips · $2.50

Cookie

$1.25

Drink

$1.50

Chips

$1.50

Dressings

Oil

Vinegar

Mayo

Ranch

Italian

Mustard

Brown Mustard

Cheese

Provolone

Swiss

Cheddar

White American

Pepper Jack

Veggies

Lettuce

Tomato

Onion

Pickles

Sweet Peppers

Hot Peppers

Black Olives

Hungry for a tray?

Trays for parties, offices, and game day.